Shirin Akiner - tanqid ostida

[UzLand]

text - http://www.voanews.com/uzbek/Experts-criticize-British-scholar.cfm

audio - http://www.voanews.com/mediaassets/uzbek/2005_07/Audio/ram/00423264.ram

[Gareeb]

Ikkiyuzlamachilar ha erda topiladida. Ogzim bor ekan, baribir aytganimni isbotlay olishmaydi deb yozavergan shekillida. Bu Uzb uchun ayni muddao. Kimsan Angliyalik expert hisoboti deb jar solishadi.

[referee]

we need to bear in mind that Shirin Akiner is very close Uzbek leaders, she relies on their cooperation for her research trips to Uzb-n. The question how comfortably close should a researcher get to his subject of research? Akiner seems to suggest very close....

[driver]

zorku, 2 kunda 40 kishi yana viloyat hokimi orinbosari bilan :))

lekin o'ziyam manimcha oldindan tayallangan qogirchoq odamlar bilan suhbat bogan bosa kere=)
uyida 2 talab mavt chiqazgan oilalani 40 tasi bilan ikki kunda gaplashishi iloji borakanmi a? qiziq...
uzoq yoldan kegin o'zi kamida 10 soat uhlagan bosa kere...yana uni ustiga vodiyni choyhonasida nonushta yoki bitta tushlik qilish uchun 1 soat kamlik qiladi....
keling aytaylik 1 kuni u tushdan kegin soat 3:oo pm da o'z "tadqiqot" ini boshlagan bosa 4 soat deylik ...bu qisqa muddat ichida faqatgina maximum 6 honadon bilan gaplashish mumkin....ikkinchi kuni maylim vohliro turdilatime difference tufayli....10 soat ishladila 14 ta honadon da suhbat qurdila.....
atigi 20 ta chiqvotti....osha 20 ta honadon ham manimcha organ hodimlari tomonidan qorqitilaverip oddiygina poshshomiz yaxshila dip qoygan bolishsa kerak...
shirin akinerninng DC ga shuncha pul harjlab kelishlari ulani ahmoqliklaridan belgi...chunki faqat ahmoqgina bu yolgonni oilap topa olishi...ee yolgon gapirganindan kegin uni ishonchli ham qilishi kerede a? nima didila?
eee UK dayam topilarkanda bunaqa ikkiyuzlamachila tovba qildim.....

[maradona]

Shirin Akiner - tanqid ostida , Shirin Akiner hamisha haqiqatni kuylagan ;)

Andijon viloyat hokimini urinbosari bilan birga ishlagan bulsa demak , barcha malumotlar shuhbasiz tugri deb hisoblayman ;)

Bu temani forumga olib chiqishni menimcha keragi ham yuk edi :rolleyes:

[UzLand]

yana uni ustiga vodiyni choyhonasida nonushta yoki bitta tushlik qilish uchun 1 soat kamlik qiladi....

Хокимиятда тушлик бир соат билан чекланмайди:)