Capital in the borders

[Fortunato]

Hello Forumistes

Can any one explain to me

1) why almost all the Central Asia countries had there capitals almost in the borders

ex:
Tachkent in the border with Kazakhstan
Bishkek almost in the border with Kazakhstan
Ashkabat almost in the border with Iran
Of course Almaata has been changed to astana (in the centre)

2) Is there any plant to remove the capital from the border to the centre
3) Via which country most of the good transit before reaching Uzbekistan

http://www.advantour.com/uzbekistan/information/map.htm

Thanks in advance
Fortunato

[Uzbekxonim]

2) Is there any plant to remove the capital from the border to the centre
3) Via which country most of the good transit before reaching Uzbekistan



2) it is not that easy just to remove the capital to some other place, cos it's an administrative centre, it is historically developed center (after Samarqand)

3) depends from which country you're coming from and by what means (plain, car, train)

[Royal]

Yap, they was planning to move capital to Samarqand but, Tashkent say NO, so Samarqandies say: OK if Capital dont come to us that we come to Tashkent!!!

So they doing so!

[Royal]

Yap, they was planning to move capital to Samarqand but, Tashkent say NO, so Samarqandies say: OK if Capital dont come to us that we come to Tashkent!!!

So they doing so.

Samarqandlikla Toshkentga butunlay kochib kegandan keyin Toshkentlikla poytahtni olib Samarqandga kochishsa kerak...

[Pythagor]

Yap, they was planning to move capital to Samarqand but, Tashkent say NO, so Samarqandies say: OK if Capital dont come to us that we come to Tashkent!!!

So they doing so.

Samarqandlikla Toshkentga butunlay kochib kegandan keyin Toshkentlikla poytahtni olib Samarqandga kochishsa kerak...demak, oz qopti...

[Fortunato]

2) it is not that easy just to remove the capital to some other place, cos it's an administrative centre, it is historically developed center (after Samarqand)

3) depends from which country you're coming from and by what means (plain, car, train)

Hi Uzbekhonom

Thanks for reply

2- I know it is not easy to remove any capital to an other city, but Possible :) but many countries did it, Kazakhistan, Turkey, Brasil and many others

3- When i say "Goods" I mean heavy machinery, usualy tranport by ships to the capian sea, (cheaper way of transport)

Any ideas why buit first on the border?

[Fortunato]

Yap, they was planning to move capital to Samarqand but, Tashkent say NO, so Samarqandies say: OK if Capital dont come to us that we come to Tashkent!!!

So they doing so.

...

:cool: And Tashkent still say no?

[Uzbekxonim]

2- I know it is not easy to remove any capital to an other city, but Possible :) but many countries did it, Kazakhistan, Turkey, Brasil and many others


even if it is possible it isn't worth - too many expenses. even if some other countries did so it doesn't mean that Uzbekistan should repeat their actions, and what's wrong with the thing that tash is almoast on a border? it doesn't bother anyone.


Any ideas why buit first on the border?


I don't know why Uzbek capital was established on a border. if you're that interested in that you make a search in Uzbek history.

[Fortunato]

even if it is possible it isn't worth - too many expenses. even if some other countries did so it doesn't mean that Uzbekistan should repeat their actions, and what's wrong with the thing that tash is almoast on a border? it doesn't bother anyone.


I don't know why Uzbek capital was established on a border. if you're that interested in that you make a search in Uzbek history.

Hi
We have a deferent understanding of Geoplitics :)

Thanks for your advice, nevertheless the advantage of the forum is to get a "normal" people opinions, I prefer to ask forumiste opinion than reading history; I m sure that somebody know and will answer me some day

Take care

[Legend]

The reason kazakhstan moved it is capital to north was a demographic factor. 51% of Kazakhstan population is Russians who mostly live in northern part of kazakhstan, while almost all Kazakhs and non- kazakhs live in the south and Center. And maybe in next 20 years Northern part of the country , where Russians mostly dominated could ask to join Russian Federation, and could cause some geopolitical problems. And then they had to move the capital to the north, to prevent this kinda actions. Because no country woud give its capital to another country. Thats all about Astana :) .

[Martingale]

The reason kazakhstan moved it is capital to north was a demographic factor. 51% of Kazakhstan population is Russians who mostly live in northern part of kazakhstan, while almost all Kazakhs and non- kazakhs live in the south and Center. And maybe in next 20 years Northern part of the country , where Russians mostly dominated could ask to join Russian Federation, and could cause some geopolitical problems. And then they had to move the capital to the north, to prevent this kinda actions. Because no country woud give its capital to another country. Thats all about Astana :) .

Agree 100%;)

[Royal]

The reason kazakhstan moved it is capital to north was a demographic factor. 51% of Kazakhstan population is Russians who mostly live in northern part of kazakhstan, while almost all Kazakhs and non- kazakhs live in the south and Center. And maybe in next 20 years Northern part of the country , where Russians mostly dominated could ask to join Russian Federation, and could cause some geopolitical problems. And then they had to move the capital to the north, to prevent this kinda actions. Because no country woud give its capital to another country. Thats all about Astana :) .
Toppa togri oshanga yaqinda Toshkentni Samarqandga oborishsa keray, po printsipu gepolitikie deganday....ulayam oqigan ....